BriefHistory.us
America250 — 250 years since 1776. Explore two and a half centuries of American history. Start the tour
Home / Guides / U.S. Foreign Policy Doctrines Explained
Guide · List

U.S. Foreign Policy Doctrines Explained

From nonentanglement to containment — the ideas that have organized two centuries of American power.
A nineteenth-century diplomatic chamber with a globe, folded maps, and treaty documents lit by a tall window

American foreign policy has rarely been written down in one place. It accumulates instead as doctrine — a presidential message to Congress, a diplomat's dispatch, a phrase in a magazine article — that hardens into an assumption about where the United States belongs in the world and what it owes the rest of it. George Washington's warning against permanent alliances shaped policy for more than a century without ever becoming law. A State Department official writing anonymously in 1947 supplied a single word, containment, and it organized the next four decades of American strategy.

Read in sequence, the doctrines describe an argument the country keeps having with itself. Each answers a specific problem — European powers eyeing the newly independent republics of Latin America, a continent lying open to the west, a China divided among rival empires, a Soviet army sitting in Eastern Europe — and each outlives the problem that produced it. The Monroe Doctrine was a defensive statement in 1823 and a justification for intervention by 1904. The 25 entries below trace that pattern from Washington's neutrality through the war on terror, arranged in the order the arguments arrived.

Nonentanglement, 1789–1823

The young republic's first foreign policy was to have as little of one as possible. Washington warned against permanent alliances, Jay's treaty bought time with Britain, and Monroe told Europe to stay out of the hemisphere, all from a country too weak to enforce much of anything beyond its own coastline.

After the Cold War

The collapse of the Soviet Union left American policy without the adversary every doctrine since 1947 had been built around. September 11 supplied a new organizing threat, but terrorism was a method rather than a state, and a war against it proved far harder to define, and to end.

Further Reading
Special Providence Start here
Walter Russell Mead · 2001
4.1 (592)
The clearest map of the traditions that the doctrines draw on; the best single starting point.
View on Amazon
George F. Kennan · 1951
4.1 (733)
A primary source: the architect of containment on the policy tradition he was reacting against.
View on Amazon
Henry Kissinger · 1994
4.3 (9,643)
A practitioner's account of how American doctrines fit into the longer history of great-power diplomacy.
View on Amazon
John Lewis Gaddis · 1982
4.1 (866)
The standard account of the doctrine that organized the Cold War.
View on Amazon
George C. Herring · 2008
4.2 (1,347)
The comprehensive reference that places every doctrine in its chronological context.
View on Amazon
Robert Kagan · 2006
3.9 (420)
Challenges the nonentanglement story for the first century of American policy.
View on Amazon
Walter A. McDougall · 1997
3.9 (333)
A compact survey organized around the doctrines themselves.
View on Amazon
Jay Sexton · 2011
3.9 (162)
The one book devoted to the doctrine that started the tradition.
View on Amazon
John Lewis Gaddis · 2004
3.6 (276)
Links the post-2001 doctrine to its nineteenth-century precedents.
View on Amazon
Charles A. Kupchan · 2020
3.9 (87)
The fullest treatment of the nonentanglement tradition that the later doctrines displaced.
View on Amazon
As an Amazon Associate, BriefHistory earns from qualifying purchases. Links are affiliate links; prices are unchanged for you.

The Cold War doctrines get their fullest treatment in the Cold War guide, and the overseas expansion that produced the Open Door and the Big Stick is followed in American Empire.