BriefHistory.us
America250 — 250 years since 1776. Explore two and a half centuries of American history. Start the tour
Documents · Supreme Court Decisions

Marbury v. Madison

The 1803 ruling that established the Supreme Court's power to strike down laws

Illustration of the Supreme Court chamber during the Marbury v. Madison decision, 1803
AI-generated

Marbury v. Madison is the foundational case of American constitutional law — the moment when the Supreme Court claimed the authority to declare acts of Congress unconstitutional and made that claim stick. The facts were almost comically petty: William Marbury was a minor judicial appointee confirmed in the final hours of John Adams's presidency, whose commission was withheld by the incoming Jefferson administration. He sued Secretary of State James Madison to force its delivery. Chief Justice John Marshall, writing for a unanimous Court in February 1803, gave Marbury nothing — and in doing so, gave the Court everything.

Marshall's reasoning was a masterwork of strategic jurisprudence. He ruled that Marbury was legally entitled to his commission, then ruled that the law granting the Supreme Court authority to issue the order Marbury requested was itself unconstitutional. By striking down a minor provision of the Judiciary Act of 1789, Marshall established the principle of judicial review — the power of the courts to nullify legislation that conflicts with the Constitution — without giving Jefferson anything to defy or Marbury anything to enforce. Jefferson was furious but trapped.

The decision went essentially unchallenged as precedent for the next 54 years. When the Supreme Court next struck down an act of Congress, it was in the Dred Scott decision of 1857 — one of the most disastrous rulings in the Court's history, which suggests that Marshall's restraint in selecting his moment had been wise. Judicial review is now so embedded in American constitutional practice that it is difficult to imagine the legal system without it — which is precisely what Marshall intended.

The midnight judges

The case grew out of the bitter election of 1800. Having lost both the presidency and Congress to Thomas Jefferson's Democratic-Republicans, the Federalists used their last weeks in power to fill the courts. The Judiciary Act of 1801 created 16 new federal circuit judgeships, and a separate law for the District of Columbia let the president appoint as many justices of the peace as he thought necessary. Adams named dozens of loyal Federalists. Because the Senate confirmed many of them in the final days of his term, Republicans mocked them as the "midnight judges."

William Marbury, a Maryland-born financier and Federalist organizer, was named a justice of the peace for Washington County, in the district. His commission was signed and sealed, but no one delivered it before Adams left office on March 4, 1801. The man responsible for delivering it was the outgoing secretary of state, John Marshall, who had already been confirmed as chief justice and held both jobs at once. When the Court heard the case, Marshall did not step aside.

Why the Court waited two years

Marbury and three other unseated justices of the peace filed suit in December 1801. Before the Court could rule, the new Republican Congress repealed the Judiciary Act of 1801 and abolished its judgeships. It then passed a law that canceled the Court's June and December 1802 terms, so the justices could not meet again until February 1803. Many Federalists saw the delay as an attempt to keep the Court from ruling on the repeal itself.

The Jefferson administration treated the case with open contempt. Madison never answered the suit, and the government sent no lawyer to argue its side.

How Marshall built the opinion

Marshall organized the decision around three questions. Did Marbury have a right to his commission? Yes, because it was complete once signed and sealed. Did the law give him a remedy? Yes, a court order called a writ of mandamus, directing an official to do his legal duty. Could the Supreme Court issue that writ in this case? No.

The Judiciary Act of 1789 appeared to let Marbury bring his suit directly to the Supreme Court. Marshall held that Article III of the Constitution lists the only kinds of cases the Court may hear first, and Congress cannot add to the list. Faced with a conflict between a law and the Constitution, a court must follow the Constitution. "It is emphatically the province and duty of the judicial department to say what the law is," he wrote.

Did Marshall invent judicial review?

Not entirely. Alexander Hamilton had argued in Federalist No. 78 that judges must treat a law contrary to the Constitution as void. Several state courts had already set aside state laws, and in Hylton v. United States in 1796 the Supreme Court had weighed whether a federal tax was constitutional before upholding it. What Marshall did was state the principle in a formal opinion of the Supreme Court and actually apply it to an act of Congress.

Historians also note that Marbury was not treated as a landmark for most of the 19th century. Its reputation grew later, as courts and scholars looked back for the origin of a power the Court was using more often. In Cooper v. Aaron in 1958, during the fight over desegregating Little Rock's schools, the Court cited Marbury to insist that its interpretations of the Constitution bound state officials.

What happened next

A week after Marbury, in Stuart v. Laird, the Court upheld Congress's repeal of the 1801 judgeships, avoiding a direct clash with the Republicans. The administration struck back in another way. In 1804 the House impeached Justice Samuel Chase, a fierce Federalist, for partisan conduct on the bench. The Senate acquitted him in 1805, and no Supreme Court justice has been impeached since.

Marbury never became a justice of the peace. He went back to business in Georgetown and died in 1835.

Timeline

  1. February 24, 1803Marbury v. MadisonThe 1803 ruling that established the Supreme Court's power to strike down laws
Further Reading
The Great Decision Start here
Cliff Sloan and David McKean · 2009
3.9 (398)
The accessible narrative of the case and the politics around it; start here.
View on Amazon
William E. Nelson · 2000
The standard short scholarly treatment, revised and expanded in 2018.
View on Amazon
Robert Lowry Clinton · 1989
The principal revisionist reading of what Marbury actually decided.
View on Amazon
As an Amazon Associate, BriefHistory earns from qualifying purchases. Links are affiliate links; prices are unchanged for you.

Related entries

Featured in these guides

Across the Brief network

People in this entry, on BriefPeople